Books and
Readers in Ancient Greece and Rome by F. C. Kenyon was published by
Oxford University Press in 1932. A second edition (from 1951) was
reprinted in the beginning of the 21st century. This old book is
still quite interesting.
Frederic
George Kenyon (1863-1952) was a British scholar, who specialised in the
classical world and biblical history. After graduating from Oxford University he joined the British Museum where he held a series of
positions, the last of which was Director and Principal Librarian (1909-1931).
The four
chapters of this book are slightly expanded versions of three lectures which
the University of London asked him to deliver at King’s College in
March 1932. Here are the chapter headings:
I. The Use
of Books in Ancient Greece
II. The
Papyrus Roll
III. Books
and Reading at Rome
IV. Vellum
and the Codex
At the end
of the book we find an appendix with illustrative passages from Latin authors
and an index. There is no bibliography.
The text is
illustrated with nine pictures and drawings, all in black-and-white. The
illustrations are few but they are well-chosen. I like in particular the illustration on
the plate facing page 56: “Teacher and Students with Rolls.”
This relief was discovered in Neumagen. Today it is on display in the Rheinisches Landesmuseum,
[See: Stanley Bonner, Education in Ancient Rome, paperback, 1977, 1992]
In chapter
I about books in ancient Greece, Kenyon mentions an anecdote about Socrates
(469-399 BC), which demonstrates that books were a common product at this time:
Socrates says the works of the philosopher Anaxagoras could be bought by anyone
for a drachma (page 20).
In chapter
II about the papyrus roll, Kenyon mentions the ancient historian Charles Henry
Oldfather (1887-1954) and his book The Greek Literary Texts from Greco-Roman
Egypt, from 1923. This work is an important source for the information about
the papyrus roll.
In chapter
III about books in ancient Rome , Kenyon mentions Lucius Asinius
Pollio - a friend of the poets Horace and Virgil – who was the founder of the
first public library in Rome (pp. 79-80).
In chapter
IV about the vellum codex, Kenyon mentions the conflict between Ptolemy V
Epiphanes, ruler of Egypt ca. 204-ca. 180 BC, and Eumenes II, ruler of Pergamum
197-159 BC:
“Eumenes tried to steal Ptolemy’s librarian, inviting Aristophanes
of Byzantium, then chief of the great Alexandrian Library, to come to his court
at Pergamum; whereupon Ptolemy put Aristophanes in prison.”
[pp. 87-88]
In this
chapter Kenyon also explains the transition from roll to codex. The papyrus
roll was a vehicle for the pagan writings of ancient Greece and ancient Rome , while the vellum codex was a
vehicle for the writings of the Christian church.
The roll
has an important disadvantage: it is quite difficult to locate a specific
passage, because you are dealing with a long roll. The codex is more
user-friendly: it is much easier to locate a specific passage, because you are
dealing with individual pages.
In this
chapter Kenyon gives us the long view: the papyrus roll was used for a thousand
years (from ca. 600 BC to ca. AD 400), after which it was gradually replaced by
the vellum codex, which was also used for a thousand years (from ca. 400 to ca.
1400), until it was replaced by the book printed on paper, which is now being
replaced - or supplemented - by the digital book (obviously, the detail about
the digital book does not come from Kenyon).
I like this book, but some sections are very technical; a bit too technical for my
taste; in particular pp. 48-56 about the roll and pp. 106-109 about the codex. On page 109 the
author admits as much: “I have dealt at length and in some detail with the form
and history” of ancient books. Indeed he has! Kenyon was a palaeographer. He
was very interested in ancient documents written on papyrus. I think this is
why he sometimes gives us so much technical information.
The
appendix at the end of the book contains a useful collection of illustrative passages
from Latin authors which are divided into several categories: (1) the materials
of books; (2) the form of books; (3) the end of the book; (4) the fate of bad
books (they end up as wrapping paper); (5) book-boxes; (6) the book trade; (7)
books and reading.
The first long
excerpt from Pliny the Elder is given in Latin and in English, which is fine;
unfortunately, the remaining short passages are only given in Latin.
Kenyon’s
book is not perfect. Some minor flaws have already been mentioned above. To
them I will add the following observation: I think he is too optimistic when discussing
how early writing was used in ancient Greece and too pessimistic when discussing
how late writing was used in ancient Rome . But most of this book is interesting
and easy to read, even though it was written more than 80 years ago.
If you are
interested in ancient history, in particular ancient libraries and ancient
literacy, I think you will enjoy this slim volume from 1932.
* * *
PS. The original version from 1932 is available as an e-book on the internet.
You can read it online or download it to your computer.
* * *
No comments:
Post a Comment