The first
edition of Lonely Planet’s guidebook to Libya (written by Anthony Ham) was
published in 2002. I had it with me on a trip to Libya in 2004 during which I was able to
check some of the information presented in the book.
I visited
the ancient sites on or near the northern coast in the western part of the
country (Tripolitania ) and in the eastern part of the
country (Cyrenaica ). But I did not visit the southern
part of the country (Fezzan ), so I was not able to check what the book says about this area.
This book
gives you information about local transport (how to get from A to B). There is
also information about hotels and restaurants. But most visitors will not need
any of this information, because they will travel on a package tour, where a
travel agency will arrange local transport and pick the hotels and restaurants.
Because of Libya ’s special visa system and the rules
for foreigners, it is (almost) impossible to travel on your own. You must
travel with a group and follow a fixed itinerary. But this does not have to be
a bad thing.
What you
need from a guidebook about Libya is general information about the history
of the country and specific information about the sites you are going to visit.
A local guide will probably show you around, but it is always good to know
something about the place in advance.
Using my own
experience as a yardstick I have to say that this is a good guidebook which
gives you a lot of useful information. However, I have to mention a few minor
flaws:
(a) On pp.
150-151 we hear about the monumental tombs of Ghirza. Anthony Ham says:
“the
northernmost tomb features particularly fine stonework atop some of the
pillars, and a Roman eagle above the door with Latin inscriptions.”
In fact, it
is quite the opposite: above the door of the northern tomb (known as Tomb A) there is a Latin inscription
flanked by two Roman eagles.
(b) Under
the heading “Getting there” we are told:
“The best option is a long (six hour)
day trip from Misrata.”
This timeframe is not
realistic. When we travelled to Ghirza, it took the driver five hours to drive from Misrata to
Ghirza, because the road is rather bad. If you spend three hours at the site,
including one hour for lunch, and then return to Misrata, you will need thirteen
hours for the whole trip. It is a long day, but in my opinion, Ghirza is
worth a visit.
(c) On page
153 we hear about Medinat Sultan and the Italian arch which once stood here.
Ham writes about the two bronze statues of the Philaeni brothers:
“The hollow
statues once stood more than 5 m tall atop the arch demarcating Tripolitania from Cyrenaica .”
In fact,
the statues were lying down then, just as they are when you see them today. One
of them was facing west towards Tripolitania , while the other was facing east
towards Cyrenaica .
(d) On the
same page a sidebar with the heading “The division of Libya ” explains how the Greeks and the
Romans divided Libya between them in the 4th century BC. This explanation is not true. The Greeks and the Carthaginians did this. One
pair of runners was Greek; they started from Cyrene and moved west. The other pair was
Punic; they started from Carthage and moved east. The point where the
two pairs met would mark the border between the two cities. Rome had nothing to do with this. The
Romans did not come to Africa until much later. So whenever Ham says “Roman,” the word should be
changed to “Punic.”
The story
about the division of Libya is told by the Roman author Sallust
in his book about the war with Jugurtha, chapter 79.
(e) On pp.
168-169 we hear about the ancient church of Qasr Libya :
“Also of
great importance is panel 23, a Byzantine inscription stating that
the mosaics were laid in AD 339.”
In fact, the
mosaics were laid in 529-530, after the Byzantine conquest of North Africa , as stated on the preceding page.
(f) Further
on Ham mentions a Turkish fort “which has fine views over the surrounding
countryside.”
When I was there, I climbed
to the roof of the fort, but I was unable to see anything, because the walls
are about two meters high. The only way to view the
surrounding countryside from this fort is if you bring you own ladder!
Apart from
these minor flaws, I like this book. The first edition from 2002 is still quite
useful, although of course the section about recent history is not quite up-to-date.
The following events happened after the book was published:
* In May
2006 the US removed Libya from its list of states suspected
of supporting terrorism.
* In August
2008 the US and Libya signed an agreement about mutual
compensation for any damage the two states might have caused each other.
* In
September 2008 US Foreign Secretary Condoleezza Rice made an official visit to Libya during which she met with the
Libyan leader colonel Kadafi; the first official visit by a US foreign secretary since 1953. These
events marked the fact that the two countries had re-established diplomatic
relations with each other
* The UK re-established diplomatic relations
with Libya in 1999, and in March 2004 the British Prime
Minister Tony Blair made an official visit to Libya during which he met with Kadafi.
* * *
Anthony
Ham,
First
edition, 2002, 264 pages
* * *
No comments:
Post a Comment